PATHS TO COLLEGE AND CAREER
  • Home
  • The Curriculum
    • Grade 6
    • Grade 7
    • Grade 8
    • Grade 9
    • Grade 10
    • Grade 11
    • Grade 12
    • Contact Sales
  • Resources
    • Paths Videos
    • Papers, Briefs, Research
    • Tools
  • Services
    • Paths Implementation Support
    • Standards Implementation
  • More...
    • About
    • Contact Us

PCG Education ​Voices 

The Dangers of Low Expectations

1/31/2018

6 Comments

 
Paul Wilson
Picture
​“He has a rough home life, he will always struggle.”
“He can’t do the work, so I only make him do a portion of it.”
“He will never be able to do it, so why should I even bother?”

​The three statements above didn’t come from a journal article or from observing a teacher. Each one was made about me as I was growing up as a knucklehead in Miami, FL: The first statement was made by my 1st grade teacher, the second by my 4th grade teacher, and the third by my 9th grade Algebra teacher. All three affected my psyche in various ways, all negative. However, these comments aren’t just about me. The statements above illustrate a much larger issue in public education today. 

Despite the considerable attention paid to this problem, there still seems to be a culture of low expectations that is applied to certain students depending on risk factors like race, socio-economic status, and academic history. Generally speaking, these expectations are not applied with malicious intent behind them. In fact, most teachers feel they are helping a student, protecting them from embarrassment or alienation, by not holding them to the same standards as everyone else. However, holding a student to low expectations helps perpetuate a fixed mindset, which will be detrimental to the student as they matriculate through grade levels.

As a former administrator and teacher in a large urban school district, I have seen this scenario play out time and time again. Although we know many students who enter the classroom can learn more than they are expected to, many of the teachers responsible for delivering the content and guiding students do not share the same sentiment. Consequently, when teachers have low expectations for some students, especially those who had a history of struggling, living in poverty or are transient, those students are often ostracized and separated into small groups based on perceived ability. You know the ones: the “Bears” and the “Tigers” ability groups all kids can see through. The students know what those groups represent, as do the general stakeholders around the school. Those designations often represent the stigma of low expectations that teachers have with students. The students in groups of perceived lower ability receive less rigorous curriculum or intervention support.

These low expectations can continue to plague classrooms and students for years, especially if the classroom is populated with students that may have performed poorly on standardized testing. If a student receives a level 2 on an assessment, for example, they are likely to be viewed as a "Level 2" student year after year. Hard to move away from that when no one truly believes they can. We as educators understand that test scores can follow a student more doggedly than discipline referrals from the principal's office or a criminal record. If a student is pegged as a Level 2, more than likely they may never be able to break the stigma of that label until it is far too late. They get Level 2 curriculum, Level 2 expectations, and Level 2 support. Then, we scratch our heads, baffled, trying to figure out why they have dropped out or left the school system with a negative attitude about schools and education.

That would’ve been the case with me, if I didn’t have an opportunity to meet that one teacher who changed my perspective on education. Whoever said that “sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me” is a liar. Lucky for me, I met Mr. Diamond, a teacher who changed those statements into ones like, “I don’t care where you come from, you can do whatever you put your mind to” and “I know it’s hard, but I have your back, so keep going” and finally, “I believe in you, you should believe in you too.” This teacher held me to high standards and exposed me to rigorous curriculum, and these things made a difference.
​
Words matter more than we think, and communicating positive beliefs towards students is the only way we will be able to shift the paradigm in public education from a culture of low expectations and low rigor to a culture of academic optimism. Offering every student the opportunity to engage with rigorous curriculum is more than just kind: it’s critical. 
6 Comments
Andrea Williams
2/1/2018 11:32:41 am

Excellent article and timely subject. Words absolutely matter and then earlier we begin to change the words, the better for children.

Reply
Sheila Anthony
2/1/2018 11:39:49 am

Wow, this was moving. It speaks volumes, this is also me growing up in Miami,Fl. I was told as a little girl that test scores defined you and that if I didn’t score average or above average I wasn’t smart enough or I would have to be placed in a lower leveled class. Hearing that as a little girl really killed my sprits and some of my dreams. I also developed low self esteem and had major behavioral problems. To make a long story short , I too met a teacher my 10th grade year , Mrs.Duty and Mrs.Humprey 11th grade year. These two strong African American Female teachers gave me hope, life, courage, and strength and told me I can do anything I want to do in life. With determination, drive, passsion, my wittiness ,I can be a lawyer , judge, Doctor , or the next female president. We need more uplifting educators and more possitive reinforcement these days in our schools and at home. I can write a book and go on and on but I’ll stop here. Thank you for sharing this with me Mr.Wilson

Reply
Jodi Peters
2/1/2018 12:13:07 pm

Well said Mr. Wilson - well said! Every student deserves a Mr. Diamond! The power of words to destroy or uplift - should never be underestimated. One simple vote of encouragement or discouragement can change a child's trajectory forever. Be kind, challenge one another and be the coach we all need!

Reply
Farrah Wilson
2/3/2018 07:55:20 am

Words matter especially nowadays when they are not just spoken they are in print and have the potential to go viral and can leave one feeling as if they can’t escape the them. Low expectations coupled with negative images of how others may view you makes for a daily battle for self worth and acceptance. When I was growing up my dad would always say “don’t speak that over my child” if anyone said something negative. At the time, I didn’t see the importance but now that I have two African American sons to raise it hits home on a daily basis. Making them feel worthy, accepted, and loved, along with my husband, is our responsibility when the world that we live in constantly judges them and sets low expectations for them just from how they look!

Great post Mr. Wilson definitely something to bring to the forefront because until we can have courageous conversation nothing will ever change.

Reply
Nina Roselle
2/9/2018 10:58:23 am

"Words matter more than we think, and communicating positive beliefs towards students is the only way we will be able to shift the paradigm in public education from a culture of low expectations and low rigor to a culture of academic optimism. Offering every student the opportunity to engage with rigorous curriculum is more than just kind: it’s critical." This is brilliant!

Marva Collins and her Westside Academy is a terrific historical model of what you're saying. The following is from a New York Times Article about her:

"Ms. Collins set high academic standards, emphasized discipline and promoted a nurturing environment. She taught phonics, the Socratic method and the classics and, she insisted, never expected her students to fail."

Reply
Alex Mosleys link
12/30/2020 04:49:07 am

Lovely postt

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    ABOUT US

    PCG Education, a division of Public Consulting Group, works with schools, school districts, and state education agencies to build their capacity for instructional and programmatic improvements.

    ARCHIVES

    April 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017

    CATEGORIES

    All

    RSS Feed

148 State Street     |     Boston, Massachusetts 02109     |     800-210-6113      |     paths@pcgus.com
© 2020 Public Consulting Group, Inc.
Terms of Use        Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • The Curriculum
    • Grade 6
    • Grade 7
    • Grade 8
    • Grade 9
    • Grade 10
    • Grade 11
    • Grade 12
    • Contact Sales
  • Resources
    • Paths Videos
    • Papers, Briefs, Research
    • Tools
  • Services
    • Paths Implementation Support
    • Standards Implementation
  • More...
    • About
    • Contact Us